Question
Which combination of sand, gravel, and activated charcoal makes muddy water clearest?
Sample hypothesis
If activated charcoal is included, then the water will come out clearest, because charcoal traps small particles and dissolved substances.
Write your own version after your research. See how to write a hypothesis.
The science behind it
Water treatment plants use layers: gravel and sand catch particles of different sizes, and activated carbon absorbs some dissolved chemicals and color. Filtering makes water clearer but does NOT make it safe to drink; that takes disinfection.
Materials
- 4 clean 2-liter bottles, cut in half (adult)
- Coffee filters or cotton balls
- Gravel, coarse sand, fine sand
- Activated charcoal (aquarium supply)
- Muddy water (soil + water mixed)
- Clear cups
- Ruler and a printed black-and-white target card
Procedure
- Turn bottle tops upside down into the bottom halves to make funnels. Plug each neck with a coffee filter.
- Fill each with different layers: (A) gravel only, (B) gravel + sand, (C) gravel + sand + charcoal, (D) sand + charcoal.
- Stir the muddy water and pour exactly 300 mL through each.
- Measure clarity: place the target card under a tall clear cup and add filtered water until you can no longer see the target. A deeper reading means clearer water.
- Record the time to filter as well.
- Repeat 3 times with fresh filters.
Variables
| Independent (you change) | Filter layer combination |
|---|---|
| Dependent (you measure) | Clarity (cm of visibility) and filtering time |
| Controlled (keep the same) | Same muddy water mixture; Same layer depths; Same pour volume |
Data and graph
Bar graph of clarity by filter type; photos of before-and-after cups. See data tables and graphs.
Safety
- Do NOT drink the filtered water
- Adult does bottle cutting
- Wash hands after handling muddy water
General rules: science fair safety.
Take it further
Contact your local water utility (Aiken, SC residents can look up the city's annual water quality report) and compare your filter with real treatment steps.